A/HRC/27/38
Mr. Cau had participated by means of an audio message at a side event called “Banned civil
society voices” on 4 February 2014, before the universal periodic review of Viet Nam had
taken place. Mr. Cau had been under surveillance since March 2013 and had been detained
on 1 January 2014 on suspicion of carrying terrorist materials as he was boarding a plane
for Ho Chi Minh City and placed under house arrest. Although he had reportedly been told
orally that he could travel freely within the country, Mr. Cau was rearrested on 16 February
2014 and taken to Truong An district police station, where he was interrogated about his
audio message at the side event. On 14 April 2014, Mr. Cau was informed by an official of
the Thua Thien-Hue police that he would remain under house arrest for the duration of the
investigation of his case. At the time of finalization of the present report, no reply had been
received from the Government.
40.
Pham Chi Dung, a journalist, writer and independent analyst, was reportedly
prevented from travelling to Geneva to participate in a side event convened on 4 February
2014 in connection with the universal periodic review of Viet Nam. On 30 January 2014,
Mr. Dung was visited at his home by three officers of the People’s Security Forces, who
expressed concern about his scheduled trip to Geneva. Mr. Dung was invited to appear at
the Ho Chi Minh Police Department on 1 February 2014, which he declined to do. As he
checked in for his flight to Geneva at Ho Chi Minh International Airport on 1 February
2014, Mr. Dung was stopped by two security officers, who confiscated his mobile phone
and passport, and informed him that he was barred from leaving the country.
Approximately one hour later, Mr. Dung was allowed to return home, but his passport was
not returned.55 A reply to a joint communication sent on 31 March 2014 by three special
procedures mandate holders was received on 11 July 2014 from the Government, in which
it stated that the allegations were inaccurate and that preventing Mr. Dung from boarding
the flight to Geneva did not relate to his legal human rights activities.56
C.
Follow-up information on cases included in previous reports
1.
India
41.
The case of Teesta Setalvad, Secretary of Citizens for Justice and Peace, which
provides legal support to the victims of the Gulbarg Society massacre, was mentioned in the
2011 report on cooperation with the United Nations, its representatives and mechanisms in
the field of human rights.57 A reply was received on 27 July 2011, in which the Government
stated that it had examined the matter and it would be inappropriate to comment since the
matter was sub judice.58 On 4 January 2014, officials from the Gujarat Crime Branch
reportedly filed a First Information Report against Ms. Setalvad and Javeed Anand, editor
of the magazine Communalism Combat, allegedly for embezzlement of a large sum of
money provided for the construction of the Gulbarg Society massacre memorial. They were
subsequently charged with several offences including criminal conspiracy. On 10 January
2014, Ms. Setalvad and Mr. Anand were reportedly granted interim bail by the Bombay
High Court, which observed that Ms. Setalvad had been falsely implicated in the past. The
hearing was reportedly adjourned to 23 April 2014.59 At the time of finalization of the
present report, no reply had been received from the Government to a joint communication
sent on 11 April 2014 by three special procedures mandate holders.
55
56
57
58
59
14
A/HRC/27/72, case VNM 5/2014.
Ibid.
A/HRC/18/19, paras. 42-47.
A/HRC/18/51, case IND 5/2011.
A/HRC/27/72, case IND 3/2014.