A/HRC/54/61
Ms. Tannagasheva took the floor as a civil society organization representative at the EMRIP.
As she finished her statement, she was approached by a representative of the Permanent
Mission of the Russian Federation to the United Nations in Geneva, who asked her name,
phone number and her business card [in a reportedly aggressive manner]. 73 They also
addressed the allegation of the subsequent removal of related content from the website of a
partner organization where the International Committee of Indigenous Peoples of Russia, the
organization Ms. Tannagasheva is a member of, had uploaded a statement on the incident.
Reportedly the hosting provider of the website received an e-mail with a request from the
Russian authorities to remove the page from the Internet within 24 hours. Mandate holders
expressed concern that the reported incident of intimidation may have a significant chilling
effect on the participation and freedom of expression of representatives of indigenous peoples
in the EMRIP and the Human Rights Council, from the Russian Federation and beyond
(RUS 15/2022).
101. On 12 and 13 April 2023, during the dialogue between the Committee on the
Elimination of Racial Discrimination and the delegation of the Russian Federation in regard
to the Committee’s consideration of the Russian Federation’s twenty-fifth and twenty-sixth
periodic reports, the Committee sought clarifications on the reported attempt to intimidate
Ms. Tannagasheva as she was making a statement at the session of the United Nations Expert
Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (EMRIP) in July 2022 and the reported
request by the authorities to the organization represented by Ms. Tannagasheva to remove
the statement they published in their website about the incident at EMRIP (CERD/C/SR.2959
para. 28). The Committee recommended in its concluding observations that the State party
conduct effective, thorough and impartial investigations into all reported cases of
intimidation and harassment of, and threats and reprisals against, human rights defenders,
journalists, lawyers, activists and members of civil society organizations
(CERD/C/RUS/CO/25-26, para. 19).
21.
South Sudan
102. The Secretary-General, the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights
and the Commission on Human Rights in South Sudan reiterated ongoing concerns about
undue restrictions to civic and political space and the continued harassment, intimidation,
arbitrary arrests, detention, and ill treatment of journalist, human rights activists and other
individuals expressing views critical of the Government.74
103. The United Nations Mission in South Sudan (UNMISS) human rights division
documented two separate incidents of intimidation and death threats against two individuals
for their collaboration and engagement with the United Nations. A relative of one of the
individuals was also the target of reprisals for the cooperation of the individual with the
Mission. Names and details of those concerned are withheld due to fear of further reprisals.
104. The UNMISS human rights division also documented several instances where civil
society actors expressed fear of coming under Government surveillance or of having their
organizations infiltrated by individuals affiliated or working for the Government. Civil
society shared concerns about Government surveillance through the monitoring of their
phones or/and the tracking of their movements. This reportedly contributed to a general
climate of fear, which negatively impacted the ability of civil society to cooperate with the
Mission.
105. The United Nations Commission on Human Rights in South Sudan reported having
gathered testimonies of members of the public, journalists, human rights activists and
members of civil society organizations who feared having their cases raised by the United
Nations, because of risks of reprisals against them, their families, and organizations they may
be affiliated with. Some civil society members told the Commission that they were worried
73
74
GE.23-15378
https://media.un.org/en/asset/k1r/k1rjz6g7a7.
S/2023/135, para. 96; S/2022/918, para. 73; A/HRC/52/26 paras. 19–23;
https://www.ohchr.org/en/statements-and-speeches/2023/03/strengthening-accountability-and-civicspace-critical-south-sudans.
37