A/HRC/42/30
Annex I
Comprehensive information on alleged cases of reprisals
and intimidation for cooperation with the United Nations
on human rights
1.
Algeria
1.
In July 2018, the Human Rights Committee called on Algeria, as a matter of
urgency, (a) to guarantee that individuals who cooperate with the Committee are not
subjected to any form of intimidation or reprisal; and (b) drop the charges against, release
and compensate all individuals who are being prosecuted, either directly or by way of other
charges, for having cooperated with the Committee (CCPR/C/DZA/CO/4, para. 8 (b)).
2.
Bahamas
2.
In October 2018, Ms. Alicia Wallace, from Equality Bahamas working on women’s
rights and gender-based violence, engaged with the Committee on the Elimination of all
forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) in the context of the review of
Bahamas. Equality Bahamas submitted a public alternative report to CEDAW and Ms.
Wallace travelled to Geneva to deliver an oral statement during the CEDAW session on 24
October 2019. In the following days, Ms. Wallace’s statement was reportedly echoed in
local newspapers and was read aloud by the host of a popular radio talk show, Freedom
March. During the radio show, the host made disparaging comments about CEDAW, and
about Ms. Wallace and her colleagues, including related to their engagement with the UN.
The host reportedly displayed pictures of Ms. Wallace and her colleagues and criticized
their advocacy. This episode reportedly worsened an already hostile environment for Ms.
Wallace, who in 2014 had received death threats on Facebook in connection to her work on
violence against women.
3.
On 30 May 2019, CEDAW sent a letter to the State party addressing these
allegations. On 22 June 2019, the Government responded and noted that, upon receipt of
the allegations, the relevant authorities started an investigation, contacted Ms. Wallace to
obtain more information about her situation, and offered her assistance through the Gender
Based Violence Specialist, Department of Gender and Family Affairs. The Government
expressed concern about the allegations stating that it will seek to protect the rights and
safety of women defenders in the country.
3.
Bahrain
4.
In July 2018, the Human Rights Committee noted with concern a large number of
reports of reprisals against Bahraini human rights defenders and journalists because of their
work, particularly when they collaborate with United Nations treaty bodies and the Human
Rights Council (CCPR/C/BHR/CO/1, para. 59). The Committee noted with concern the
cases of Mr. Sayed Ahmed Al-Wadaei and Ms. Ebtesam Abdulhusain Ali-Alsaegh (see
Annex II).
5.
On 19 June 2019, the Government responded, stressing that competent authorities
do not charge, arrest, imprison or take reprisal measures against anyone for working with
the United Nations. It is the view of the Government that any allegations of intimidation or
acts of reprisal against individuals or their families because of their human rights work are
untrue and false; and anyone making such allegations is merely trying to cover up the fact
that legal proceedings against them or any of their relatives are owing to violations and acts
prohibited or criminalized by national law. Regarding the travel ban on Ms. Ebtesam
Abdulhusain Ali-Alsaegh, the Government indicated that a judicial order was issued in
April 2017 barring her from travel as part of a different case where she was charged with
20
GE.19-15332