A/HRC/42/30
by the Israeli Ministry of Strategic Affairs which lists civil society organizations working
on human rights in the Occupied Palestinian Territories (OPT), which the Ministry claims
promote boycotts against Israel, and calls for halting financial support from European
Union (EU) institutions to these organizations. In the report, the Ministry notes the
involvement of these human rights organizations in anti-Israel delegitimization and the
promotion of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement.
63.
Among the activities included under the umbrella of anti-Israel delegitimization
were support for the creation of a database on businesses that have enabled, facilitated and
profited from the construction and growth of Israeli settlements in the OPT, as requested by
Human Rights Council (resolution 31/36), and petitioning the UN Secretary-General on
further issues related to business and human rights in the OPT. In January 2019, a second
report 84 alleging ties between NGOs promoting BDS and terrorist organizations was
published by the Ministry. It includes information on their engagement with the Human
Rights Council, the 2009 UN fact-finding mission on Gaza, and their petitioning of the UN
Secretary-General on issues relating to business and human rights in the OPT. The report
calls on governments and donor organizations providing funds to these organizations to halt
such support.
64.
In their letter, the three special procedures mandate holders also raised concerns
about reported harassment of staff members of a Palestinian human rights organization
while participating in side events and in private meetings with OHCHR staff during the
Human Rights Council in March 2019 (ISR 8/2019). The special procedures mandate
holders note they were followed and photographed by staff members of an organization
reportedly involved in discrediting members of Palestinian civil society.
65.
On 31 July 2019, the Government responded in detail,85 rejecting alleged attacks on
civil society organizations operating in Israel and the Palestinian territories and referring to
the 2017 UPR in which it emphasized the recurring opportunities for dialogue and free
discourse between civil society, academia and government representatives. Regarding the
alleged stigmatization, the Government noted that despite the important role NGOs play in
Israeli society, they are not “immune from criticism” and stated that BDS organizations
often hide behind human rights claims. It noted that the Ministry of Strategic Affairs in its
reports revealed direct links between BDS-promoting NGOs and designated terrorist
organizations, information which it has aimed to provide to the EU and other European
countries so they could re-examine the transfer of funds and make sure they are used for
their intended purpose.
66.
Regarding the claims of intimidation at the March 2019 Human Rights Council, the
Government stated that these are “unfounded accusations hidden behind the veil of
anonymity” and it cannot respond to claims against an Israeli NGO whose identity is
unknown.
21.
Kazakhstan
67.
In March 2019, the New Generation of Human Rights Defenders Coalition,
established to coordinate civil society inputs to the third cycle of the UPR of Kazakhstan,
was reportedly subject to surveillance, called for questioning related to their cooperation
with the UN, and had their private channels of communication compromised. Between 20
and 30 March 2019, two National Security Service (KNB) officials reportedly called for
questioning a representative of the Coalition and inquired about their activity. The two
officials were privy to detailed information on the discussions of the Coalition, and
specifically referred to an encrypted message exchange (through an intercepted WhatsApp
chat) that the Coalition had used to coordinate input to the UPR. The questioning occurred
the same week that the Coalition sent its UPR submission on Kazakhstan to the United
84
85
30
https://4il.org.il/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/The-Money-Trail-2nd-Edition-January-2019.pdf.
Response from Government: https://spcommreports.ohchr.org/TMResultsBase/
DownLoadFile?gId=34808.